Merkava: Difference between revisions

From 2d4chan
Jump to navigation Jump to search
1d4chan>LordRao1
m (48 revisions imported)
 
(18 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
{{topquote|The borders are drawn where the treads stop.|IDF Armored Corps Motto}}
{{topquote|The borders are drawn where the treads stop.|IDF Armored Corps Motto}}


The Merkava was a third generation MBT designed to replace the ageing [[M60 Patton|Magach 6]]. It is equipped with a licensed M68 105mm main cannon: the same gun from the [[M60 Patton]], one to two turret mounted FN MAGs, with one browning .50 cal mounted coaxially. A uniquely Israeli invention, the Merkava compromises on battlefield survivability and speed in favour of armour and crew survivability.
The Merkava was a third generation MBT designed to replace the ageing [[M60 Patton|Magach 6]]. It is equipped with a licensed M68 105mm main cannon: the same gun as found on the [[M60 Patton]], one to two turret-mounted FN MAGs, with one browning .50 cal mounted coaxially. A uniquely Israeli invention, the Merkava compromises on battlefield survivability and speed in favour of armour and crew survivability.




Line 13: Line 13:
The Merkava comes in two flavours, the Mk.1 and the Mk.2. Both come with a 105mm cannon, while the Mk.2 stacks on even more armour on this thing.
The Merkava comes in two flavours, the Mk.1 and the Mk.2. Both come with a 105mm cannon, while the Mk.2 stacks on even more armour on this thing.


Here's the thing: this is a terrible tank against NATO forces. with a 105mm gun for AT19, you'll have a next to impossible chance when trying to punch through [[T-64|T-64s]] and literally all shots will bounce from an [[M1 Abrams|M1IP Abrams]]. Conversely, your armour is less of an issue for high-end tanks with AT22 like the [[Chieftain]] and the [[T-64]]. Fortunately, they do come with brutal and excel in a combined arms role where they can attack the weakest points in the enemy line while your [[Pereh|ATGMs]] focus on taking down the deadliest tanks your opponents have.
Here's the thing: this is a terrible tank against armoured forces: with a 105mm gun for AT19, you'll have an almost negligible chance when trying to punch through [[T-64|T-64s]] and literally all shots will put nice scratches on the armor of an [[M1 Abrams|M1IP Abrams]]. Conversely, your armour is less of an issue for high-end tanks with AT22 like the [[Chieftain]] and the [[T-64]]. Fortunately, they do come with ''Brutal'' and excel in a combined arms role where they can attack the weakest points in the enemy line while your [[Pereh|ATGMs]] focus on taking down the deadliest tanks your opponents have.


The Mk.1 is a very heavily armoured beast with tiny arms. With front armour 18 and bazooka skirts with side armour 6, the Mk.1 needs to be focused down with ATGMs to reliably take out. It might have decent firepower against infantry, but lacks the advanced stabilizers of modern tanks. The Mk.2 ups the armour to a front armour 19, and side armour 7 and BDD armour. It will lose a tank fight most of the time, but will absorb quite a few missiles before going down and the low costs lets you bring quite a few of them.
The Mk.1 is a very heavily armoured beast with tiny arms. With front armour 18 and bazooka skirts with side armour 6, the Mk.1 needs to be focused down with ATGMs to reliably take out. It might have decent firepower against infantry, but lacks the advanced stabilizers of modern tanks. The Mk.2 ups the armour to a front armour 19, and side armour 7 and BDD armour. It will lose a tank fight most of the time, but will absorb quite a few missiles before going down and the low cost lets you bring quite a few of them.


Interestingly, the Mk.2 almost seems tailor-made to counter Milan spam. With Brutal ROF2 on the move and 2+ to bounce against AT21, you should expect a unit of these to wreck havoc against British and French spam. It may not have the anti-tank capability of the [[Chieftain]] or a [[T-72]] but is likely to become a staple unit to counter Milan spam.
Interestingly, the Mk.2 almost seems tailor-made to counter Milan spam. With Brutal ROF2 on the move and 2+ to defeat AT21 weapons, you should expect a unit of these to wreak havoc against British and French Milan spam. It may not have the anti-tank capability of the [[Chieftain]] or the [[T-72]], but is likely to become a staple unit in the current Milan-heavy meta.


Adding on to the combined arms approach of the Merkava, it can fire 4 shots at infantry in the open much like the [[M1 Abrams]].  
Adding on to the combined arms approach of the Merkava, it can fire 4 shots at infantry in the open much like the [[M1 Abrams]].  


A Mk.1 costs 6 points per tank, coming in platoons of 2-3 while the Mk.2 costs 7 per piece.
A Mk.1 costs 6 points per tank, coming in platoons of 2-3, while the Mk.2 costs 7 points apiece.
 
Vs the M1IP:
Worse side armor, same frontal.
Worse AT on the main cannon, but brutal, accurate over M1IP.
MGs will spit more lead and the .50 will deal more damage to any light vehicles.
Slower, worse cross.
Much better points cost, if you can keep front to the enemy, it's the same wall o' steel that the IP gives but at lower cost, and with an infantry shredding main cannon.


{{clear}}
{{clear}}
Line 27: Line 34:
==IRL==
==IRL==


[[File:Merkava 2 II main battle tank israeli army israel 002.jpg|300px|left|thumb|Shabbat Shalom Motherfuckers!]]
[[File:Merkava 2 II main battle tank israeli army israel 002.jpg|300px|left|thumb|Shabbat Shalom, Motherfuckers!]]
[[File:4gimyhhd84d21.jpg|300px|right|thumb|Don't tug on Superman's cape, kid.]]
[[File:4gimyhhd84d21.jpg|300px|right|thumb|Don't tug on Superman's cape, kid.]]
While America was screwing around in Vietnam, the Israelis were researching how their tanks could lose against the ATGM spam of three other nations. Concluding that helicopters were sitting ducks in the desert environment, the Israelis decided that the tank would be the one doing the most fighting in their battles. So, rather than waiting for the Cold War to advance weapons technology at a snail's pace, the Israelis decided to design their own Main Battle Tank.
While America was screwing around in Vietnam, the Israelis were researching how their tanks could lose against the ATGM spam of three other nations. Concluding transport helicopters were sitting ducks in the desert environment, the Israelis decided that the tank would be the one doing the most fighting in their battles. So, rather than waiting for the Cold War to advance weapons technology at a snail's pace, the Israelis decided to design their own Main Battle Tank.


As Israel's homegrown tank, the Merkava takes many liberties with conventional tank design. For starters, instead of having the driver in the front, turret in the middle, and engine in the back, the Merkava places the engine forward to act as an extra buffer against shrapnel, leaving the back available for a rear entrance for emergency exits. This configuration made it easier to preserve the far more valuable crew: tanks were replaceable, but experienced tankees were not. With the standard ammo complement, a Merkava could house up to 4 additional troops if absolutely required.  
As Israel's homegrown tank, the Merkava takes many liberties with conventional tank design. For starters, instead of having the driver in the front, turret in the middle, and engine in the back, the Merkava places the engine forward to act as an extra buffer against shrapnel, leaving the back available for a rear entrance for emergency exits (also very useful when dug into a hull-down position). This configuration made it easier to preserve the far more valuable crew: tanks were replaceable, but experienced tankers were not. With the standard ammo complement, a Merkava could house up to 4 additional troops if absolutely required.  


In a pinch, they were even used as APCs and medical evac units if ammo racks were significantly reduced, giving space for up to six men and their equipment: eight to ten if ALL ammo racks were thrown out. Depending on the mission requirements, some Merkavas were even converted into impromptu mortar carriers as in the first and second Intifadas. Uniquely, this is one of the few non-Soviet tanks designed to fire ATGMs.
In a pinch, they were even used as APCs and medical evac units if ammo racks were significantly reduced, giving space for up to six men and their equipment: eight to ten if ALL ammo racks were thrown out. Depending on the mission requirements, some Merkavas were even converted into impromptu mortar carriers as in the first and second Intifadas. Uniquely, this is one of the few non-Soviet tanks designed to fire ATGMs.
Line 37: Line 44:
The Merkava served well against enemy [[T-62M|T-62s]] and was largely immune to infantry AT weapons at the time, though later Merkava models were upgraded to use the advanced Trophy active defense system. In 2008, the IDF introduced a dedicated APC based on the Merkava called the Namer. The modern design is the Merkava IV, which features a 120mm gun and modular armour plating for faster repairs. Today, the IDF is working on the 'Barak' upgrade package which will give tank commanders the same type of helmet as that seen in the F-35, allowing them to easily see outside the vehicle without popping their heads outside. It also improves on existing battlefield communication systems and installs a modified baseball machine to fire projectiles at incoming missiles.
The Merkava served well against enemy [[T-62M|T-62s]] and was largely immune to infantry AT weapons at the time, though later Merkava models were upgraded to use the advanced Trophy active defense system. In 2008, the IDF introduced a dedicated APC based on the Merkava called the Namer. The modern design is the Merkava IV, which features a 120mm gun and modular armour plating for faster repairs. Today, the IDF is working on the 'Barak' upgrade package which will give tank commanders the same type of helmet as that seen in the F-35, allowing them to easily see outside the vehicle without popping their heads outside. It also improves on existing battlefield communication systems and installs a modified baseball machine to fire projectiles at incoming missiles.


In the meantime, the Israel military and defense industry have decided to not rest on their laurels. Despite having one of the best tanks in the world, they are already designing a supplement and eventual replacement called the Carmel. Since normal shells would be less effective, they plan to give it a 40-76mm autocannon that is able to load HEAT and HESH rounds, or use '''railguns or direct energy weapons'''.
In the meantime, the Israel military and defense industry have decided to not rest on their laurels. Despite having one of the best tanks in the world, they are already designing a supplement and eventual replacement called the Carmel. Since normal shells would be less effective, they plan to give it a 40-76mm autocannon that is able to load HEAT and HESH rounds, or use '''railguns or direct energy weapons'''. Do take it with a grain of salt, as, well... Its presentation trailer is making it look like it's made of Unobtanium and powered by unicorn farts or something.  


{{Israeli Forces in Team Yankee}}
{{Israeli Forces in Team Yankee}}

Latest revision as of 22:31, 21 June 2023

YES MA I DID REMEMBER TO TAKE OFF THE MUZZLE CAP!

"The borders are drawn where the treads stop."

– IDF Armored Corps Motto

The Merkava was a third generation MBT designed to replace the ageing Magach 6. It is equipped with a licensed M68 105mm main cannon: the same gun as found on the M60 Patton, one to two turret-mounted FN MAGs, with one browning .50 cal mounted coaxially. A uniquely Israeli invention, the Merkava compromises on battlefield survivability and speed in favour of armour and crew survivability.


In Team Yankee[edit]

The Stats, Magad!
And the fatter Merkava.

Do you like tanks? This thing a tanky tank.

The Merkava comes in two flavours, the Mk.1 and the Mk.2. Both come with a 105mm cannon, while the Mk.2 stacks on even more armour on this thing.

Here's the thing: this is a terrible tank against armoured forces: with a 105mm gun for AT19, you'll have an almost negligible chance when trying to punch through T-64s and literally all shots will put nice scratches on the armor of an M1IP Abrams. Conversely, your armour is less of an issue for high-end tanks with AT22 like the Chieftain and the T-64. Fortunately, they do come with Brutal and excel in a combined arms role where they can attack the weakest points in the enemy line while your ATGMs focus on taking down the deadliest tanks your opponents have.

The Mk.1 is a very heavily armoured beast with tiny arms. With front armour 18 and bazooka skirts with side armour 6, the Mk.1 needs to be focused down with ATGMs to reliably take out. It might have decent firepower against infantry, but lacks the advanced stabilizers of modern tanks. The Mk.2 ups the armour to a front armour 19, and side armour 7 and BDD armour. It will lose a tank fight most of the time, but will absorb quite a few missiles before going down and the low cost lets you bring quite a few of them.

Interestingly, the Mk.2 almost seems tailor-made to counter Milan spam. With Brutal ROF2 on the move and 2+ to defeat AT21 weapons, you should expect a unit of these to wreak havoc against British and French Milan spam. It may not have the anti-tank capability of the Chieftain or the T-72, but is likely to become a staple unit in the current Milan-heavy meta.

Adding on to the combined arms approach of the Merkava, it can fire 4 shots at infantry in the open much like the M1 Abrams.

A Mk.1 costs 6 points per tank, coming in platoons of 2-3, while the Mk.2 costs 7 points apiece.

Vs the M1IP: Worse side armor, same frontal. Worse AT on the main cannon, but brutal, accurate over M1IP. MGs will spit more lead and the .50 will deal more damage to any light vehicles. Slower, worse cross. Much better points cost, if you can keep front to the enemy, it's the same wall o' steel that the IP gives but at lower cost, and with an infantry shredding main cannon.

IRL[edit]

Shabbat Shalom, Motherfuckers!
Don't tug on Superman's cape, kid.

While America was screwing around in Vietnam, the Israelis were researching how their tanks could lose against the ATGM spam of three other nations. Concluding transport helicopters were sitting ducks in the desert environment, the Israelis decided that the tank would be the one doing the most fighting in their battles. So, rather than waiting for the Cold War to advance weapons technology at a snail's pace, the Israelis decided to design their own Main Battle Tank.

As Israel's homegrown tank, the Merkava takes many liberties with conventional tank design. For starters, instead of having the driver in the front, turret in the middle, and engine in the back, the Merkava places the engine forward to act as an extra buffer against shrapnel, leaving the back available for a rear entrance for emergency exits (also very useful when dug into a hull-down position). This configuration made it easier to preserve the far more valuable crew: tanks were replaceable, but experienced tankers were not. With the standard ammo complement, a Merkava could house up to 4 additional troops if absolutely required.

In a pinch, they were even used as APCs and medical evac units if ammo racks were significantly reduced, giving space for up to six men and their equipment: eight to ten if ALL ammo racks were thrown out. Depending on the mission requirements, some Merkavas were even converted into impromptu mortar carriers as in the first and second Intifadas. Uniquely, this is one of the few non-Soviet tanks designed to fire ATGMs.

The Merkava served well against enemy T-62s and was largely immune to infantry AT weapons at the time, though later Merkava models were upgraded to use the advanced Trophy active defense system. In 2008, the IDF introduced a dedicated APC based on the Merkava called the Namer. The modern design is the Merkava IV, which features a 120mm gun and modular armour plating for faster repairs. Today, the IDF is working on the 'Barak' upgrade package which will give tank commanders the same type of helmet as that seen in the F-35, allowing them to easily see outside the vehicle without popping their heads outside. It also improves on existing battlefield communication systems and installs a modified baseball machine to fire projectiles at incoming missiles.

In the meantime, the Israel military and defense industry have decided to not rest on their laurels. Despite having one of the best tanks in the world, they are already designing a supplement and eventual replacement called the Carmel. Since normal shells would be less effective, they plan to give it a 40-76mm autocannon that is able to load HEAT and HESH rounds, or use railguns or direct energy weapons. Do take it with a grain of salt, as, well... Its presentation trailer is making it look like it's made of Unobtanium and powered by unicorn farts or something.

Israeli Forces in Team Yankee
Tanks: Merkava - M60 Patton
Transports: M113 Armored Personnel Carrier
Troops: IDF Infantry Platoon
Artillery: M109 Howitzer -M106 Heavy Mortar Carrier -M125 Mortar Carrier
Anti-Aircraft: M163 VADS - ZSU 23-4 Shilka - M48 Chaparral - Redeye SAM Platoon
Tank Hunters: Pereh - M150 TOW - Jeep TOW
Recon: M113 Recce - Jeep Recce
Aircraft: AH-1 Cobra Attack Helicopter - A4 Skyhawk