Peasant Railgun: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
m (73 revisions imported) |
||
(40 intermediate revisions by 31 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The '''Peasant Railgun''' | {{Powergamer}} | ||
The '''Peasant Railgun (DnD)''' is a weapon of mass game-breaking destruction that relies on a few basic rules in the DnD system (and total ignorance of the rules on the DM's part): readying actions and the length of a combat round (6 seconds). | |||
==Creating a Peasant Railgun== | |||
# Hire a ton of peasants; let's just say that it is two thousand two hundred and eighty. Line them up in single file; this will form a chain of peasants two miles long. It'd have been four miles back in MY day (witness me [[Old School Roleplaying|hiking up my 2nd Edition suspenders]]). | |||
# Buy a ladder. Just buy a standard, ten-foot ladder. Disassemble the ladder into a bunch of rungs and a pair of mighty ten-foot wooden poles. Hand a pole to the peasant at the back of line. | |||
# First round of combat. Peasant at the front of line readies an action to throw the pole at the enemy. Every peasant behind him readies an action to hand the pole to the peasant in front of him. | |||
# Next round: peasants fire off their readied actions, passing the pole two miles down the line and hurling it in six seconds or less. Pole accelerates to the speed of 1188 miles per hour, or Mach 1.546875 in dry air, at 20°C/68°F, at sea level on our planet. | |||
# Peasant Railgun can be reloaded and fired in less than 12 seconds. | |||
# Variations - Really, your choice. Weapon is scalable, you could use your peasant railgun to fire a number of things at a really long range. Add more peasants to make the weapons even faster; paint them red to make them fasta. Use gobbos to make a DnD grot cannon. Hurl pointy bombs for HEAT weapons. Severed heads make an impressive psychological warfare tool. It's even more wild with a bag of holding - place a team of fighters in it for DYNAMIC ENTRY over castle walls and shit, hurl some fucking [[bear cavalry]] directly into enemy lines, who knows. You can also throw a halfling monk to take full advantage of Flurry of Blows at 1200 mph and if you go with the falling object rule for 5e with the wooden rod being 7 lbs you have 5-9 lb per 60 ft do 2d6, making the rod going about 2 miles per 6 seconds [[Awesome|making it do 300d6 A TURN!!!!]] Combine this with the [[15,000,000 Gold a Day|15,000,000 gold-a-day trick]] and you're ready to [[The Henderson Scale of Plot Derailment|absolutely ruin your DM's day.]] | |||
# ???? | |||
# Motherfucking [[Profit|PROFIT]] | |||
= | ==Practical Applications== | ||
A campaign I was in recently employed a peasant railgun in a large-scale battle. Our mage was a dumb-ass and decided to launch an alchemical flask from said railgun and into the heart of the enemy forces. It blew up and killed a bunch of the enemy. Our DM got back at us by making it tear a big-ass hole in the time-space continuum. The same mage decides to approach the hole, and when he touches it, it blasts him across the fucking map and vaporizes some more enemy troops. | |||
Our mass was 3.6287896kg (8 pounds, the weight of a first edition 10 foot pole), our speed was 536.448m/s (1200 miles an hour). The final kinetic energy was 520,005 Joules. This is similar to 125g of TNT, or a half of a stick of dynamite. | |||
It's not exactly a weapon of mind blowing destruction, the math breaks it before the GM has to. It gets worse (for the weapons sake) when one considers drag, that would tear the projectile apart into a flaming swarm of splinters before it reached the end of your peasant chain. | |||
The only way this thing works is if: | |||
:a) Your GM allows for real world physics to translate into the game | |||
:b) Your GM doesn't actually know real world physics | |||
An alternative use that requires a looser DM but allows real world physics (partially) to still come into play: Instead of a regular 10-foot pole, use a heavy lance or, if your GM will allow it, a ballista bolt or whatever made of Riverine. As Riverine is stated to be immune to anything except for things like disintigrate, it can be argued that it would be immune to the compression forces and such entailed in a Peasant Railgun. Because of this, your railgun is now armed with a truly unstoppable shell. Assuming you simply extend the railgun farther, possibly by forming an open loop part way through, you can accelerate up to near light speed, allowing you to do such things as: | |||
Break the earth into a radioactive cloud! | |||
Explode the moon! | |||
Simultaneously eliminate all of existence with your near infinite mass bolt! | |||
Hold all of creation hostage! | |||
Terrify the living fuck out of your DM! | |||
And More! | |||
=== Use in [[Deep Rot]] === | |||
An Enterprising lich could utilize Skeletons in a Skellyman-Railgun to deliver goods, data bits, and important things like iron rods. If you want to communicate between lich towers, all it takes is to have a conga-line of skeletons set in underground passageways to a central facility. Shortly before the skeletons send parcels, they can send a routing key in the form of a 10-bit code, which the routing facility(And its bank of a few hundred logic skeletons), will reroute to the appropriate destination. | |||
Obviously, one could also have particle accelerators comprised of closed loops of Skeletons that infinitely accelerate steel or tungsten rods to the speed of light. Then when sentry skeletons on the tops of towers spot targets, they can spot for, and send signals back to the line to throw their rods up the tower chain, and straight at enemies. | |||
The only problem with this would be the system wasting shots on every asshole that sets foot into the tower kill-zones. So it would constantly burn through rods every day, with each tower that needs to be defended. So [[15,000,000_Gold_a_Day|other considerations]] would have to be made in order to meet the iron demands for a given set of facilities. | |||
==No Fun Allowed== | |||
Counterarguments telling people they can't do this, and mentions of "but in real life" go here. | |||
If your DM is paying attention and bothered reading the Dungeon Master Guide (right where it says Simultaneous Activity on pg. 24 and Adjudicating the Ready Action on pg. 25-26) they will know that 6 seconds is nowhere near enough to reach the end of the line and if you're not in combat, ready action can't be used. Reading the Player's Handbook (Special Initiative Actions) would also stop the railgun: readied actions happen ''before'' the action that triggered them, and this automatically disqualifies "pass an object to the next person in line" being a legal readied action, much less chaining it infinitely. | |||
They can also tell you the rules on readying actions dictate none of the peasants are ready to catch the pole, meaning they're going to drop the pole right at the start. Even if they do manage to pass it forward there's one other problem: an improvised thrown weapon has -4 to-hit, -4 to-hit for using a 2h weapon with 1h, and -2 per range increment, and impossible to throw beyond 50ft. Even if you had the implied momentum, the final peasant would have trouble hitting a stationary barrel. And ultimately the damage of a thrown weapon isn't related to how far it travels or its speed, so the DM could just rule you invented a fancy way to transport a 1d3 damage stick across the countryside. | |||
8. | If your DM has ever read a physics textbook, or has the physics knowledge of an 8 year old, the projectile would shatter under the strain and [[Grimdark|the recoil would vaporize the peasants]]. [[Gauss|20th-century railguns]] need to be rebuilt after every third shot, and they're made of stronger stuff than 0-level NPCs. | ||
Excusing all of the above objections, and assuming everything that makes this work, you still have the following completely systematic objection: a readied action doesn't let you automatically do something you would be incapable of doing. Once the projectile's velocity reached 80+ miles per hour, the next peasant in line would be incapable of catching it. This would cause the peasant to drop the projectile and all other readied actions to pass the projectile along would be lost. Even if you think the peasant could catch an 80 mph projectile, what about one moving at 200 mph, or 500 mph? Eventually you WILL reach a point where a peasant could not reasonably catch the speeding projectile, and that point is well before mach 1.5 | |||
Building on the "a readied action doesn't let you automatically do something you would be incapable of doing" argument, the DM could rule that, since under normal circumstances the peasants would be unable to move the pole more than 10 to 30 feet in six seconds, that's how far the pole travels in one round and the remaining readied actions are wasted. Building on the idea that the peasants would be unable to catch and pass forward fast-moving projectiles, the DM could call for skill or ability checks from the peasants, with escalating penalties based on how fast the pole is currently moving. These being peasants, one would fail a check almost immediately and the remaining readied actions would be wasted, with the pole having traveled almost no distance at all. | |||
Also, the DM can rule that it works up to a point. The Peasant Railgun does in fact get the pole to the last peasant... who then makes a standard non-proficient attack with an improvised thrown weapon at a 1st-level commoner's base attack bonus. | |||
Another argument comes from the railgun's selective use of rules logic and real-world logic. The rules don't specify anything about objects gaining momentum as they're passed from one person to the next, and physics don't allow the peasants to pass the object that quickly. By RAW, you have an ordinary throw from an ordinary peasant with extra hassle; by physics, you have an ordinary throw from an ordinary peasant with extra hassle, after waiting an hour for the peasant to receive thrle object. The only way this can work is if rules logic is maintained until just after the throw, then physics notices that the object just moved two miles in six seconds and decides it must have broken the sound barrier. | |||
= | ===Peasant Railgun in Warhammer 40k=== | ||
The concept of a Peasant Railgun has always been known to the Tau, who hoard every railgun in the galaxy. However, being the pussies of the 40k galaxy, with such notions as dignity and all that like, they are horrified at the idea. The Imperium, on the other hand, not being such moral joes and having a near inexhaustible supply of citizens to hurl at the enemy, are eyeing the idea with great interest... | |||
=See also= | ==See also== | ||
* [[15,000,000 Gold a Day]] | * [[15,000,000 Gold a Day]] | ||
* [[Rope Trick Bunker of Doom]] | * [[Rope Trick Bunker of Doom]] | ||
* [[Gauss|Railguns in sci-fi RPGs]] | * [[Gauss|Railguns in sci-fi RPGs]] | ||
* [[Bag_of_Holding#Shitcannon_of_Holding|Shitcannon of Holding]] | |||
[[Category: Dungeons & Dragons]] | * [[Pun-Pun]] | ||
[[Category: Dungeons & Dragons]][[Category:Gamebreaking]] |
Latest revision as of 09:24, 22 June 2023
This article or section covers stupidly cheesy and/or broken crunch that gives powergamers and munchkins a serious hard-on at the expense of everyone else. It is extremely likely to cause Rage in whoever goes against it. So don’t use it, you dick. |
The Peasant Railgun (DnD) is a weapon of mass game-breaking destruction that relies on a few basic rules in the DnD system (and total ignorance of the rules on the DM's part): readying actions and the length of a combat round (6 seconds).
Creating a Peasant Railgun[edit]
- Hire a ton of peasants; let's just say that it is two thousand two hundred and eighty. Line them up in single file; this will form a chain of peasants two miles long. It'd have been four miles back in MY day (witness me hiking up my 2nd Edition suspenders).
- Buy a ladder. Just buy a standard, ten-foot ladder. Disassemble the ladder into a bunch of rungs and a pair of mighty ten-foot wooden poles. Hand a pole to the peasant at the back of line.
- First round of combat. Peasant at the front of line readies an action to throw the pole at the enemy. Every peasant behind him readies an action to hand the pole to the peasant in front of him.
- Next round: peasants fire off their readied actions, passing the pole two miles down the line and hurling it in six seconds or less. Pole accelerates to the speed of 1188 miles per hour, or Mach 1.546875 in dry air, at 20°C/68°F, at sea level on our planet.
- Peasant Railgun can be reloaded and fired in less than 12 seconds.
- Variations - Really, your choice. Weapon is scalable, you could use your peasant railgun to fire a number of things at a really long range. Add more peasants to make the weapons even faster; paint them red to make them fasta. Use gobbos to make a DnD grot cannon. Hurl pointy bombs for HEAT weapons. Severed heads make an impressive psychological warfare tool. It's even more wild with a bag of holding - place a team of fighters in it for DYNAMIC ENTRY over castle walls and shit, hurl some fucking bear cavalry directly into enemy lines, who knows. You can also throw a halfling monk to take full advantage of Flurry of Blows at 1200 mph and if you go with the falling object rule for 5e with the wooden rod being 7 lbs you have 5-9 lb per 60 ft do 2d6, making the rod going about 2 miles per 6 seconds making it do 300d6 A TURN!!!! Combine this with the 15,000,000 gold-a-day trick and you're ready to absolutely ruin your DM's day.
- ????
- Motherfucking PROFIT
Practical Applications[edit]
A campaign I was in recently employed a peasant railgun in a large-scale battle. Our mage was a dumb-ass and decided to launch an alchemical flask from said railgun and into the heart of the enemy forces. It blew up and killed a bunch of the enemy. Our DM got back at us by making it tear a big-ass hole in the time-space continuum. The same mage decides to approach the hole, and when he touches it, it blasts him across the fucking map and vaporizes some more enemy troops.
Our mass was 3.6287896kg (8 pounds, the weight of a first edition 10 foot pole), our speed was 536.448m/s (1200 miles an hour). The final kinetic energy was 520,005 Joules. This is similar to 125g of TNT, or a half of a stick of dynamite. It's not exactly a weapon of mind blowing destruction, the math breaks it before the GM has to. It gets worse (for the weapons sake) when one considers drag, that would tear the projectile apart into a flaming swarm of splinters before it reached the end of your peasant chain. The only way this thing works is if:
- a) Your GM allows for real world physics to translate into the game
- b) Your GM doesn't actually know real world physics
An alternative use that requires a looser DM but allows real world physics (partially) to still come into play: Instead of a regular 10-foot pole, use a heavy lance or, if your GM will allow it, a ballista bolt or whatever made of Riverine. As Riverine is stated to be immune to anything except for things like disintigrate, it can be argued that it would be immune to the compression forces and such entailed in a Peasant Railgun. Because of this, your railgun is now armed with a truly unstoppable shell. Assuming you simply extend the railgun farther, possibly by forming an open loop part way through, you can accelerate up to near light speed, allowing you to do such things as: Break the earth into a radioactive cloud! Explode the moon! Simultaneously eliminate all of existence with your near infinite mass bolt! Hold all of creation hostage! Terrify the living fuck out of your DM! And More!
Use in Deep Rot[edit]
An Enterprising lich could utilize Skeletons in a Skellyman-Railgun to deliver goods, data bits, and important things like iron rods. If you want to communicate between lich towers, all it takes is to have a conga-line of skeletons set in underground passageways to a central facility. Shortly before the skeletons send parcels, they can send a routing key in the form of a 10-bit code, which the routing facility(And its bank of a few hundred logic skeletons), will reroute to the appropriate destination.
Obviously, one could also have particle accelerators comprised of closed loops of Skeletons that infinitely accelerate steel or tungsten rods to the speed of light. Then when sentry skeletons on the tops of towers spot targets, they can spot for, and send signals back to the line to throw their rods up the tower chain, and straight at enemies.
The only problem with this would be the system wasting shots on every asshole that sets foot into the tower kill-zones. So it would constantly burn through rods every day, with each tower that needs to be defended. So other considerations would have to be made in order to meet the iron demands for a given set of facilities.
No Fun Allowed[edit]
Counterarguments telling people they can't do this, and mentions of "but in real life" go here.
If your DM is paying attention and bothered reading the Dungeon Master Guide (right where it says Simultaneous Activity on pg. 24 and Adjudicating the Ready Action on pg. 25-26) they will know that 6 seconds is nowhere near enough to reach the end of the line and if you're not in combat, ready action can't be used. Reading the Player's Handbook (Special Initiative Actions) would also stop the railgun: readied actions happen before the action that triggered them, and this automatically disqualifies "pass an object to the next person in line" being a legal readied action, much less chaining it infinitely.
They can also tell you the rules on readying actions dictate none of the peasants are ready to catch the pole, meaning they're going to drop the pole right at the start. Even if they do manage to pass it forward there's one other problem: an improvised thrown weapon has -4 to-hit, -4 to-hit for using a 2h weapon with 1h, and -2 per range increment, and impossible to throw beyond 50ft. Even if you had the implied momentum, the final peasant would have trouble hitting a stationary barrel. And ultimately the damage of a thrown weapon isn't related to how far it travels or its speed, so the DM could just rule you invented a fancy way to transport a 1d3 damage stick across the countryside.
If your DM has ever read a physics textbook, or has the physics knowledge of an 8 year old, the projectile would shatter under the strain and the recoil would vaporize the peasants. 20th-century railguns need to be rebuilt after every third shot, and they're made of stronger stuff than 0-level NPCs.
Excusing all of the above objections, and assuming everything that makes this work, you still have the following completely systematic objection: a readied action doesn't let you automatically do something you would be incapable of doing. Once the projectile's velocity reached 80+ miles per hour, the next peasant in line would be incapable of catching it. This would cause the peasant to drop the projectile and all other readied actions to pass the projectile along would be lost. Even if you think the peasant could catch an 80 mph projectile, what about one moving at 200 mph, or 500 mph? Eventually you WILL reach a point where a peasant could not reasonably catch the speeding projectile, and that point is well before mach 1.5
Building on the "a readied action doesn't let you automatically do something you would be incapable of doing" argument, the DM could rule that, since under normal circumstances the peasants would be unable to move the pole more than 10 to 30 feet in six seconds, that's how far the pole travels in one round and the remaining readied actions are wasted. Building on the idea that the peasants would be unable to catch and pass forward fast-moving projectiles, the DM could call for skill or ability checks from the peasants, with escalating penalties based on how fast the pole is currently moving. These being peasants, one would fail a check almost immediately and the remaining readied actions would be wasted, with the pole having traveled almost no distance at all.
Also, the DM can rule that it works up to a point. The Peasant Railgun does in fact get the pole to the last peasant... who then makes a standard non-proficient attack with an improvised thrown weapon at a 1st-level commoner's base attack bonus.
Another argument comes from the railgun's selective use of rules logic and real-world logic. The rules don't specify anything about objects gaining momentum as they're passed from one person to the next, and physics don't allow the peasants to pass the object that quickly. By RAW, you have an ordinary throw from an ordinary peasant with extra hassle; by physics, you have an ordinary throw from an ordinary peasant with extra hassle, after waiting an hour for the peasant to receive thrle object. The only way this can work is if rules logic is maintained until just after the throw, then physics notices that the object just moved two miles in six seconds and decides it must have broken the sound barrier.
Peasant Railgun in Warhammer 40k[edit]
The concept of a Peasant Railgun has always been known to the Tau, who hoard every railgun in the galaxy. However, being the pussies of the 40k galaxy, with such notions as dignity and all that like, they are horrified at the idea. The Imperium, on the other hand, not being such moral joes and having a near inexhaustible supply of citizens to hurl at the enemy, are eyeing the idea with great interest...