Editing BadAtMagic (section)

=== Blue ===
{{mtgcard
|name=Shark Storm
|image=Shark Storm.jpg
|cost=2UU
|types=Instant
|text=All Sharks you control gain flying and +3/+0 until end of turn.
|flavor=''“Looks like it’s that time of the month.” - Baz Hogan''
|rarity=common
}}

{{mtgcard
|name=Carcharodon
|image=Carcharodon.jpg
|cost=5UU
|types=Creature - Beast, Shark
|text=Hast
Bloodthirst 2 (If an opponent was dealt damage this turn, this creature enters the battlefield with two +1/+1 counters on it.)
|flavor=''Without doubt, the biggest fish in the lake!''
|pt=6/6
|rarity=rare
}}
I would like to give it a better name. Any ideas?
:"Ancient Carcharadon"? Adding "Ancient" onto anything makes it better.

{{mtgcard
|name=Rum Smugglers
|image=Rum_Smugglers1.jpg
|cost=1U
|types=Creature - Human, Pirate
|text=Sober 1 (This creature enters the game with one -1/-1 counters on it, you may pay 1 to remove one counter, play this only when you may play a sorcery.)
|flavor=''“Where has our cargo gone?”''
|pt=2/3
|rarity=common
}}

{{mtgcard
|name=Sea Kraken
|image=Sea_Kraken.jpg
|cost=5UUU
|types=Creature - Kraken
|text=Sea Kraken is unblockable
|flavor=For when terrorizing lakes isn't enough
|pt=5/8
|rarity=rare
}}

{{mtgcard
|name=Island Retreat
|image=Island_retreat.jpg
|cost=3UU
|types=Enchantment - Aura
|text=Enchant Island<br>You can not attack or be attacked unless the creature is a ship, has island walk, or has flying.<br>If enchanted island is destroyed you may pay U to put Island Retreat on top of your library.
|flavour=Finding safety in the sea.
|rarity=rare
}}
:You could make some wicked broken Commander decks with this. Is there enchantment removal in this set?


{{mtgcard
|name=Whalerider
|image=Whalerider.jpg
|cost=4UU
|types=Creature - Whale
|text=Islandwalk<br>When Whalerider enters the battlefield, untap up to four islands you control.<br>U: Whalerider gains flying until end of turn
|pt=4/5
|rarity=uncommon
}}
:GO BACK TO URZA'S SAGA AND STAY THERE
:I can't help but agree that the untapping lands effect is a bad idea.

{{mtgcard
|name=Eroding Shores
|image=Eroding_Shores.jpg
|cost=UUUU
|types=Sorcery
|text=Destroy target Land
|flavor=In time, the tide will consume everything. Even you. - Kep'jos, the Tide Scourge
|rarity=uncommon
}}
:This is a very odd card for blue.
:To put it less politely: This is in no way blue at all whatsoever and should not be here.
::Yeah, remember, the whole set is based around water.  Just because something has to do with water, doesn't make it blue.
:I know land destruction has never been in Blue's slice of the pie, but I figured UUUU was a difficult cost. Stone rain is only 2R. I also really liked the flavor, and the cost, I feel balances it. (I mean for 1 more mana, and a less tight mana cost you can take an extra turn!) So, whats the verdict? Remove it? Change it? It stays?
::Acid Rain would like to have a word with anyone who thinks land destruction is not blue. Still, UUUU isn't that hard to cast for mono blue (read, not at all) and that might be a viable deck to play, and land destruction is usually either green, black or red. I'd say make it at least partially red, and only to a small part blue if you really want that in, like 2RU or something. 
:::Don't be stupid. Acid Rain is a color hoser, pure and simple. Furthermore, Acid Rain would never be printed under modern design rules. Furthermore, under our current design proposal, this set should have NO land destruction.
:How about halving the mana cost and changing the effect to "Tap target land. If it cannot be tapped, destroy it". Plays into blue-as-control, and also has the effect of an eroding progression. (edit: thinking it over, make it "Instant. Target player taps a land they control. If they have no untapped land, they sacrifice a land they control". Harder to snipe special lands whilst still dicking about with their power sources)

NNB: if you change in "sacrifice" it is more in flavor. There was blue card that destroy lands, but only in odd ways, like for example "mana vortex".

{{mtgcard
|name=Treasure Trove
|image=Treasure_Trove.jpg
|cost=2UU
|types=Enchantment
|text=2UU: Draw a card
|flavor=Greed in its simplest form.
|rarity=common
}}
:(This is a reprint) 
:Love the reprint. Not sure about the flavor text, but it's passable.

{{mtgcard
|name=From the Depths
|image=From_the_Depths.png
|cost=2U
|types=Enchantment - Aura
|text=Enchant Creature<br>Enchanted creature gets +3/+0 and has Islandwalk
|rarity=common
|artist=Gensoman
}}
:I like the idea of the mirrored auras, but I think they need a bit more thought put into them. +x/+0 is not very blue. Also maybe a full cycle?

{{mtgcard
|name=Stir the Sea
|image=Stir_the_sea.jpg
|cost=1UU
|types=Instant
|text=Prevent all combat damage from creatures with Islandwalk this turn.
|flavor=If they are to stir in the sea and attack from behind, just simply stir the sea and watch what happens.
|rarity=common
}}

{{mtgcard
|name=Rising Sea
|image=Rising_sea.jpg
|cost=1U
|types=Enchantment - Aura
|text=Enchant land<br>Enchanted land is an Island
|flavor=Every drop rises the sea.<br>"Well then, that is A LOT of drops."
|rarity=common
}}