Science Fantasy

From 2d4chan
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page is needs images. Help plz.
Sci-Fantasy is a little like this.

Science Fantasy is one of the harder Setting Aesthetics to describe. Abstracted into one single sentence, it is a setting including elements from both traditional fantasy and science-fiction. It can take many forms, for science fantasy spans the whole gamut between "Hard Science-Fiction, but something like psionics/magics/... that cannot be explained by science exists" to "Fantasy, but what people call 'magic' is actually surviving hyper-advanced technology from a lost age".

Science fantasy dates all the way back to the origins of fantasy as a whole. See, despite modern "purist wars", science fiction and fantasy weren't considered really distinct from each other in the early days. As a result, you had lots of things like magical aliens, barbarians wielding laser pistols as they rode across post-apocalyptic worlds, time traveling sorcerers, and so forth. (The most telling example is Conan the Barbarian, archetypal Fantasy hero, encountering space-faring travellers in his adventures.) It's a very fertile aesthetic, and is not going to be going anywhere any time soon.

Science Fiction vs. Science Fantasy[edit]

Its worth pointing out that there are settings which technically qualify as science fantasy but are generally not considered one due to the fantasy aspects being used very sparingly.

Star Trek is probably the most notable example of this, as it does have things such as Q and the Prophets but they are rarely featured, hence why Star Trek is generally considered to be just science-fiction. It also helps that such intrusions of Fantasy elements are treated in a true Science Fiction-y way: Q and similar "Godlike" entities are viewed as merely a "sufficiently advanced Alien" in the Arthur C. Clarke sense (and we are shown the flipside, how Picard & Crew look like Gods to sufficiently primitive aliens, in a couple of ST:TNG episodes), and the Prophets are mainly used as a method to have time-related shenanigans, or have some religion vs. science debate where the divine entity (A) explicitly exists, (B) is explainable as "sufficiently advanced and unusual aliens", and (C) aren't jerks, just bad at communication with those of us who experience time linearly.

Dune provides another good example: While there are plenty of mystical and "magical" elements, they are examined the same as any other natural phenomena; the religious elements are used purely for in-universe-manipulation, not treated as in any way true.

Star Wars, on the other side of the line, explicitly has mystical elements without explanation that are treated as mystical both in-universe and by the authors.

This is edifying for the dividing line between Science Fantasy and Science Fiction: How the "magical" elements are treated is usually more important than what, exactly, those elements are in determining what genre you are in.

Hard Fantasy[edit]

A somewhat special case in the Science Fiction vs. Fantasy argument: There exists a classification known as "Hard Fantasy", where there is a magic system, yes, but the author goes out of their way to spell out all the important details, and tries to follow through on the logic of such a system.

As a general rule, if magic is regarded as an almost scientific force of nature and subject to the same sort of rules and principles, you have Hard Fantasy.

Interestingly, it's possible to mix "Hard Fantasy" with a "Soft Magic" system, where the exact mechanics of magic are left vague; this can happen when the costs and limits of magic are clear, even as the exact mechanics are not. For example, in Lord of the Rings, great things can be accomplished by "magic"[1], but it is noted that such great workings come at a great cost; Sauron, for example, poured a lot of his power into the various Rings he crafted, which in the end left him much weaker without them, but with them, particularly with the One, he was unstoppable. No particular details of how Sauron and Elves crafted their Rings are given, but the costs, and rough powers of the Rings (which, among other things, allow the user to defy entropy and act as power amplifiers) are.

This approaches Science Fantasy from the other direction, as it were. Examples of "Hard Fantasy" include Exalted, A Song of Ice and Fire, and Discworld.

Examples of Science Fantasy on /tg/[edit]

Star Wars: Probably the best known "Science Fantasy" setting. While it originates from outside tabletop gaming, there have been vast numbers of roleplaying, miniature and board games set in Star Wars. Indeed, the West End Games RPG laid the foundation for everything that wasn't in the films or Lucas's notes.

Superhero Settings: While individual heroes can be relatively pure Science Fiction, Horror, or Urban Fantasy, when you start glomming them together and try to make it make sense, you usually wind up in Science Fantasy pretty easily. (Yes, it still counts as /tg/; Mutants & Masterminds, Champions, Villains and Vigilantes, Superworld, dedicated Splat for generic systems like GURPS or Savage Worlds, and over a dozen licensed games based on DC Comics and Marvel Comics all exist, and that non-exhaustive list doesn't even get into systems based on Japanese style super heroes.)

Numenera: A world presented in classic fantasy style... except it's actually set on an Earth billions of years into the future; all of the "magic items" are actually hyperscience devices whose underlying principles have been forgotten, spellcasters are either using psionics or hypertech gizmos, and the various non-humans and monsters are aliens from other worlds/dimensions, genetically engineered lifeforms, or robots.

Warhammer 40,000: Literally beginning its existence as "Warhammer Fantasy IN SPACE!", 40K is a classic example of the "tech first, fantasy second"( or is it "fantasy first, tech second" ?) aproach to Science Fantasy. The Space Marines are techno-knights cum paladins, the Eldar are spacefaring elves, Dark Eldar tap into all sorts of "nasty faerie boogeyman" archetypes, psionics is essentially magic with sci-fi trappings, the orks are literally just orcs with guns and spaceships...

Expedition to the Barrier Peaks: This Advanced Dungeons & Dragons adventure module revolves around a band of Greyhawk adventurers exploring the ruins of a long-crashed alien spaceship.

Blackmoor: Is a Dungeons & Dragons setting in a world full of advanced science, and it's canonically the pre-apocalyptic past of Mystara. It's also the setting for the adventure modules "Temple of the Frog" and "City of the Gods".

Torg: Original in the sense it allowed multiple "realities" to co-exist (and duke it out) on Earth, so your average party could very well consist of a clusterfuck of a cyborg Hulk, a prehistoric era shaman with his stone-tipped spear summoning a dinosaur to ride in battle, a suave Indiana Jones-esque adventurer and a ninja using both supernatural ninja powers and a machinegun.

Feng Shui: Put it like this; this is a world where psionic monkeys and cyborg techno-barbarians coexist alongside shapeshifting animals, ninjas and sorcerers.

RIFTS: Just... where do we start with RIFTS? To quote our frenemies on TVtropes: The tabletop RPG Rifts is set a few centuries after the high-tech world of tomorrow is utterly trashed by the return of magic. Human supremacist armies of cyborgs, chemically-enhanced supersoldiers, and Humongous Mecha traipse across the landscape. Atlantis has risen. Sorcerers summon demons and raise the dead. Rifts in spacetime spew out critters from other dimensions more or less at random. Elves and dragons and goblins (oh my) roam the wilderness. Killer cyborgs from another dimension want to kill all humanoid life on Earth. Gods battle Alien invaders. Vampires openly run entire cities. And that's just the tip of the iceberg.

Shadowrun: A world where The Magic Comes Back meets cyberpunk, so you've got dragons running megacorporations, elves with laser pistols, dwarves building killer robots and cyborg orcs & trolls all duking it out on the mean streets.

Pathfinder: Shamelessly using this trope, Pathfinder has everything from a "crashed alien spaceship in a land of barbarians" region on the planet itself to sourcebooks detailing the other worlds in the solar system, so you can involve interplanetary travel as much as you like. Its successor/spin-off Starfinder is basically Pathfinder set 1000 years later, so everyone lives in space after Golarion vanished.

Starfinder: AKA "Pathfinder IN SPACE". More Science Fiction to Pathfinder's High Fantasy, and thus even further into Science Fantasy.

Draenei: A race from World of Warcraft who originated on an alien planet, were rescued from demonic invaders by angel-like beings made of divine magical energy, and traveled to Azeroth in gargantuan fortresses magically propelled between worlds.

Escaflowne: An isekai anime in which fantasy races conduct war centered around the use of Guymelefs; knight-like giant clockpunk mecha powered by the crystalline hearts of dragons.

The later books of the Discworld started to veer into Science Fantasy; towards the end of the series, it became sort of a steampunk series with wizards in it.

Monte Cook wrote a splatbook all about this concept for Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition called "Arcana of the Ancients".

Exalted, as a setting, arguably approaches Science Fantasy from the other side; it's a very Fantasy setting, with a very finite cosmology very different from our own; and yet, it frequently has Science Fictiony trappings (Mecha and a lot of social science fiction, notably) in keeping with it veering heavily in the Hard Fantasy direction.

And finally[edit]

When you get down to it, Dungeons & Dragons even in its initial early years throws in a lot of science concepts, Often from the pulpy side from Expedition to the Barrier Peaks with a crashed space ship, Giant space hamsters, Aberrants from behind the stars, and tons of source and ecology books that give a surprising level of detail to monsters and magic. Like Hard Fantasy, The wider D&D multiverse doesn't operate on a modern understanding of physics but on that wacky seventeen, eighteen, and nineteen hundred speculative future and pulp fiction. Genre is always dependent on the current section, so treating the world as a pure magical medieval or pulpy anything goes world is up to group preference.

We list it separately because it has multiple sub-settings that are especially Science Fantasy, so as not to break up the main list. Here are those settings:

  • Dragonmech: A Dungeons & Dragons setting where the collapse of the moon and resultant cataclysm has prompted the various races to emigrate into city-sized magic-powered mecha.
  • Dragonstar: A Dungeons & Dragons setting where magic and science coexist, allowing for an interstellar empire run by dragons where cyborg wizards duke it out with laser-packing orcs.
  • Spelljammer: A Dungeons & Dragons campaign setting that revolves around using magical ships (and by ships we mean "sail the seven seas" type) to fly between "crystal spheres" (fantasy solar systems) by way of an alternate dimension called the Phlogiston.
  • Eberron: Another D&D campaign setting. Eberron is based in "wide magic", where sufficiently understood magic is indistinguishable from technology. While the baseline mixes pulp of the Industrial Revolution and the Interwar, many applications wouldn't be out of place in science fiction: Instead of sinks, bathrooms have devices that magically clean the user's everything, portals to the moons (and perhaps even beyond) are possible, artificial limbs of both the magical and biological alien variety exist and two types of aliens seek to invade it.
  1. And it is explicitly spelled out that the Elven word for what Hobbits call "magic" is "craft" or "skill"